What You May Not Know About the MV-1

Posted by on Monday, August 16th, 2010

You may have heard some rumblings in the media lately about a new company named VPG and an accessible vehicle they’ve engineered.  The vehicle is called the MV-1, and it’s being marketed as the first “purpose-built” accessible vehicle in the industry, which means it’s built from the ground up to be accessible.

VPG maintains that a purpose-built design will better address user needs than current mobility industry offerings. In reality, disabled customers have consistently told us they want to drive the same vehicles that everyone else drives. In addition, 95% of our BraunAbility customers have told us that they’re highly satisfied with their vehicles.

Recently VPG took the MV-1 on a nationwide tour in an attempt to generate publicity. We’d like to draw your attention to the vehicle as well. Before you fall for any of the hype around the PR campaign, please keep these considerations in mind.

Limited Interior Space: The most obvious issue with the MV-1 is its lack of interior space. Wheelchair maneuverability appears to be very limited, as well as seating options. For example, if the front passenger seat is in place, a wheelchair passenger cannot sit in the mid-seat position. On the other hand, BraunAbility vehicles offer the MOST interior space and maneuverability in the industry. We make it simple to get in, move around, and easily use the vehicle.

Wheelchair Users Cannot Drive the Vehicle: Obviously, this is a major obstacle if you’re used to the freedom of driving your own vehicle. Based on previews, the MV-1 cannot be driven by a wheelchair user unless the user is able to transfer. To date, no model has been shown with a removable driver’s seat. In addition, the MV-1 does not have a power door, and the power ramp is an expensive option. BraunAbility vehicles have standard power ramps, a standard power sliding door, and flexible seating options to enable the wheelchair user to easily enter, exit and drive our vehicles.

Fuel Economy: At over 6,000 lbs, this is a very heavy vehicle with a large V8 engine. Fuel economy is estimated at 14 mph, and given the potential for gas prices to increase in the future, that’s not a very practical purchase for most people. In contrast, BraunAbility minivans have an EPA rating of 17 mph in the city, and an impressive 24 mph on the highway.

Reliability and Durability: The MV-1 is untested and unproven. It has not seen a day of service and has no experience in any capacity – as a personal vehicle, as a taxi, nothing. Ralph Braun created the first accessible vehicle nearly 50 years ago. Since the early 1990′s, the Braun Corporation has converted over 50,000 vehicles. Do you have the confidence that the MV-1 will have the same reliability and durability as a BraunAbility vehicle?

Parts and Service: Without a nationwide dealer network like BraunAbility offers, where exactly would you take your MV-1 when it breaks down? Good question, and the answer is unclear. At this point it appears VPG will be using Ford dealers for service and parts for the power train. As for where you find service and parts for the rest of your vehicle…well, your guess is as good as ours.

Compressed Natural Gas Option: VPG brags that they offer the CNG option, but they don’t talk too much about the $5000 price tag that comes along with it; nor do they mention the reduced interior space (from the CNG tanks) and reduced driving range.

Limited Choice: Although VPG puts different paint schemes on the MV-1 to designate different uses, there’s really only one configuration. Braun offers a full product line-up from three manufacturers (Chrysler/Dodge, Toyota, and Honda) and a variety of entry systems to address many customer needs across a wide range of prices.

This list of considerations is just a start, and we’ll all be hearing more about this vehicle in the coming months. With over 50 years of mobility experience behind us, we can safely say that the time-tested and trusted benefits of a BraunAbility vehicle easily outweigh this newcomer.

Tags: , ,

3 Responses to “What You May Not Know About the MV-1”

  1. Kim@NewMobilityBlog Says:

    I wrote an article about this and although I’m a **very happy** Braun Entervan owner (and plan to continue to be in the future), there are some aspects about the MV-1 which could be appealing to the disabled non-driver. I completely understand where you are coming from with your points, but I do think it’s important to have options available for the disabled/mobility impaired community as a whole.

  2. Bryan Says:

    Sounds like Braun is being very defensive in this posting….

    Unfortunatetly buying a car and then spending as much as the car cost on a conversion is not appealing to a lot of people. My hopes are that VPG can sell a bunch of these cars regardless if they arent as good as the acclaimed Braun equipped minivans, at a real low price forcing aftermarket conversion shops to lower prices. Its time for something to change and I think VPG’s MV-1 is just another step toward making vehicle prices for people with disabilities fare and giving us one more option other then a minivan. It’s 2010 and its about time that we have vehicles that we dont have to pay extra for.

    Why doesnt Braun make a vehicle from the ground up?

    -Bryan

  3. Jack Says:

    Hi Bryan,

    If the article comes across as defensive, it is only to the extent that we are defensive of our customers and people with disabilities. We want people to find the product that best meets their needs — whether it happens to be one of our vans or not. That is why we chose to post information about the MV-1 – many of our customers have been asking us about it. While the concept of a vehicle built specifically for people with disabilities is indeed exciting, our initial evaluation has revealed the MV-1 may not live up to its promise. Make no mistake, we welcome competition. If anyone can build a better mousetrap, we will stand up and take notice. But, in our opinion at this point, the MV-1 is not that mousetrap.

    The bottom line is, we encourage everyone to test out ANY accessible van to see if it will meet their needs – BEFORE making a purchase. If everyone does this, the shortcomings of any design will become apparent.

    As for the cost of our lifts and conversions, we charge a fair price and not a penny more. Ralph Braun built his first electric scooter and started this company in 1963 to meet his own mobility needs, not to profit from people’s disabilities. As someone who has worked for Ralph for over 16 years and takes great pride in the service we and our dealers provide, any suggestion to the contrary is deeply offensive and patently untrue.

    If at any time in the future it is viable to build an accessible vehicle from the ground up, we will certainly take a hard look at this option if it will meet the needs of our customers. Until then, we will go on doing what we’ve always done – providing dependable solutions to people with disabilities as economically as we can.

    Jack

Leave a Reply